Document NameTypeFile SizeDateDescription
2013_1008(day_6)(final).PDFTrial Transcript1.06 MB2013-10-08Morning Session: direct examination and cross-examination of Paul Hsieh, Ph.D., a government research hydrologist, followed by the direct examination of Stewart K, Griffiths, Ph.D., an expert witness asked to quantify flow rates and cumulative discharge of oil from the Macondo well for the 86 days between blow-out on April 20 and shut-in on July 15
MDL_2179_100813_PM_SESSION_FINAL_PDF.pdfTrial Transcript704.20 KB2013-10-08Afternoon Session: cross-examination of Stewart K, Griffiths, Ph.D., an expert witness on the quantification of flow rates and cumulative discharge of oil from the Macondo well, followed by the direct examination and cross-examination of Aaron A. Zick, Ph.D., an expert witness on fluid phase behavior models used to calculate the total flow of oil from the Macondo well.
TREX-011485R.pdfExpert Report11.73 MB2013-10-08REDACTED Report: Expert Report of Stewart K. Griffiths
TREX-011486R.pdfExpert Report9.33 MB2013-10-08REDACTED Report: Expert Rebuttal Report of Stewart Griffiths
D-21006.2.pdfDemonstrative1.01 MB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Hunter
D-21011.2.pdfDemonstrative246.92 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Hunter
D-21500.pdfDemonstrative294.88 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Hunter
D-24368.pdfDemonstrative105.61 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Hunter
D-24388-2.pdfDemonstrative55.32 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Hunter
TREX-008628.58.1.BP.pdfCallout78.46 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-008628_Redacted_BP.pdfExhibit4.43 MB2013-10-08PNNL, 7/30/10, unreviewed estimate; handwritten notes; July 31, 2010 E-mail string among Amy Bowen, George Guthrie and others, Subject: TIME CHANGE - TELECON SCHEDULED: TODAY, Saturday, July 31, 12:30p.m. CDT RE: Flow Analysis Activities for the MC252 Well; PowerPoint Slides; July 29 and 30, 2010 E-mail string among Anne Chavez, Phillip Gauglitz and others, Subject: REMINDER - TELECON SCHEDULED: TOMORROW, Friday, July 30, 12:00p.m. CDT RE: Flow Analysis Activities for the MC252 Well; PowerPoint Slides; handwritten notes, all marked as OFFICIAL USE ONLY
TREX-008635.96.1.BP.pdfCallout115.44 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-008635.97.1.BP.pdfCallout129.51 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-008635.pdfExhibit27.32 MB2013-10-08PowerPoint slides dated July 30, 2010, marked as PREDECISIONAL DRAFT, OFFICIAL USE ONLY, CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-009361.46.pdfCallout122.88 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009361.pdfExhibit23.44 MB2013-10-08
TREX-009671.1.1.BP.pdfCallout100.90 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009671.2.1.BP.pdfCallout103.77 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009671.3.1.BP.pdfCallout130.75 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009671_Redacted_US.pdfExhibit1.42 MB2013-10-08Jan 4 - 6, 2011 E-mail string among Marcia McNutt, Kathleen Hurst and others, Subjects: Tom Hunter feedback on new data and USGS Director McNutt would like to discuss BOP forensics, marked as CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-009692.3.2.BP.pdfCallout84.10 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009692.pdfExhibit3.16 MB2013-10-08Article titled Estimates of Conditions in the Gulf, Ron Dykhuizen and Charlie Morrow, dated May 16, 2010, marked as FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY AND HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-009706.1.pdfCallout68.66 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009706.26.1.BP.pdfCallout117.22 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009706.4.pdfCallout118.54 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009706.5.pdfCallout173.00 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009706.pdfExhibit6.55 MB2013-10-08Flow Modeling Activities: Team Review With Tom Hunter, dated July 26, 2010
TREX-009718.1.1.BP.pdfCallout102.45 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009718.1.2.BP.pdfCallout94.33 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009718_Redacted_US.pdfExhibit516.01 KB2013-10-08E-mail string, top e-mail from Mr. Hunsaker to Mr. O'Connor, et al., dated July 28, 2010
TREX-009725.2.1.BP.pdfCallout72.80 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009725.pdfExhibit575.61 KB2013-10-08Handwritten notes of Mr. Oldenberg, dated 7/30/10
TREX-009906.3.3.BP.pdfCallout152.30 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009906.pdfExhibit1.17 MB2013-10-08Document titled Notes on FRTG Conference Call, July 30, 2010, marked as CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-009908.2.2.BP.pdfCallout142.78 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009908_Redacted_US.pdfExhibit811.87 KB2013-10-08Dec. 4, 2010 E-mail string between Jed Borghei, hunsaker61@comcast.net, SCHU, Subject: containment report, marked as CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-009916_Redacted_US.pdfExhibit1.69 MB2013-10-08May 17, 2010 E-mail from David Keese to Richard Garwin, Amy Bodette , et al., Subject: Additional background info for more margin, with Attachments; May 17, 2010 E-mail from David Keese to SCHU, Subject: Ball bearing impedance for more margin, with Attach
TREX-009929.95.pdfCallout63.82 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hunter
TREX-009929_Redacted_BP.pdfExhibit12.29 MB2013-10-08Collection of Dr. Hunter's handwritten notes with the first page dated 5/12/10; 120 pages
TREX-11280.1.1.US.pdfCallout297.98 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Hunter
TREX-141394.12.1.US.pdfCallout195.53 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Hunter
TREX-141394.pdfExhibit10.48 MB2013-10-08Macondo Well Integrity Test
TREX-9916.3.1.US.pdfCallout195.56 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Hunter
TREX-9916.4.1.US.pdfCallout258.79 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Hunter
D-21205.pdfDemonstrative263.30 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21207.pdfDemonstrative264.73 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21210.pdfDemonstrative290.54 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21211.pdfDemonstrative243.36 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21212.pdfDemonstrative231.61 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21213.pdfDemonstrative284.25 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21214.pdfDemonstrative159.96 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21215.pdfDemonstrative237.59 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21216.pdfDemonstrative277.52 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21217.pdfDemonstrative320.14 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21218.pdfDemonstrative259.92 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21219.pdfDemonstrative231.97 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21221.pdfDemonstrative234.69 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21222.pdfDemonstrative247.72 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21223.pdfDemonstrative261.70 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21224.pdfDemonstrative297.73 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21225.pdfDemonstrative180.93 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21226.pdfDemonstrative297.42 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21227.pdfDemonstrative316.92 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21228.pdfDemonstrative292.66 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21229.pdfDemonstrative269.86 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21230.pdfDemonstrative200.68 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21231.pdfDemonstrative180.10 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21235.pdfDemonstrative174.39 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21253.pdfDemonstrative293.31 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21255.pdfDemonstrative153.58 KB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-21301.pdfDemonstrative1.32 MB2013-10-08US Demonstrative for Hsieh
D-23401.pdfDemonstrative58.83 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-23997-1A.pdfDemonstrative72.66 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-23997-2A.pdfDemonstrative83.47 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-24368.pdfDemonstrative105.61 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-24369.pdfDemonstrative110.08 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-24370.pdfDemonstrative111.80 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-24372.pdfDemonstrative106.64 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-24374.pdfDemonstrative90.33 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-24375.pdfDemonstrative94.03 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-24376.pdfDemonstrative82.34 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-24389.pdfDemonstrative80.14 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Hsieh
D-24401.pdfDemonstrative131.27 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-24408.pdfDemonstrative103.80 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-24409.pdfDemonstrative100.33 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-24495.pdfDemonstrative106.29 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Hsieh
D-24527.pdfDemonstrative97.49 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-24531.pdfDemonstrative104.97 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
D-24532.pdfDemonstrative94.28 KB2013-10-08BP Demonstrative for Griffiths
TREX-008615.11.1.BP.pdfCallout66.42 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008615.pdfExhibit10.16 MB2013-10-08Computer Simulation of Reservoir Depletion and Oil Flow from the Macondo Well Following the Deepwater Horizon Blowout; 25 pages and Oct. 22 and 24, 2010 E-mail string between Paul Hsieh and Mark Sogge, Subject: Revised Report and revised report: A few edits to consider, with Attachments, marked as CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-008618.pdfExhibit2.02 MB2013-10-08Application of MODFLOW for Oil Reservoir Simulation During the Deepwater Horizon Crisis; five pages
TREX-008627.2.pdfCallout120.69 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008627.3.2.BP.pdfCallout69.11 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008627.pdfExhibit1.17 MB2013-10-08Email from K. Baker - P. Hsieh et al. re Science Call Follow-Up
TREX-008628.7.1.BP.pdfCallout47.30 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008628_Redacted_BP.pdfExhibit4.43 MB2013-10-08PNNL, 7/30/10, unreviewed estimate; handwritten notes; July 31, 2010 E-mail string among Amy Bowen, George Guthrie and others, Subject: TIME CHANGE - TELECON SCHEDULED: TODAY, Saturday, July 31, 12:30p.m. CDT RE: Flow Analysis Activities for the MC252 Well; PowerPoint Slides; July 29 and 30, 2010 E-mail string among Anne Chavez, Phillip Gauglitz and others, Subject: REMINDER - TELECON SCHEDULED: TOMORROW, Friday, July 30, 12:00p.m. CDT RE:Flow Analysis Activities for the MC252 Well; PowerPoint Slides; handwritten notes, all marked as OFFICIAL USE ONLY
TREX-008634.3.1.BP.pdfCallout74.67 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008634.pdfExhibit809.41 KB2013-10-08PowerPoint slides titled Analysis of shut-in pressure through July 29, 2010, Paul Hsieh, USGS
TREX-008635.74.1.BP.pdfCallout102.18 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008635.pdfExhibit27.32 MB2013-10-08PowerPoint slides dated July 30, 2010, marked as PREDECISIONAL DRAFT, OFFICIAL USE ONLY, CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-008639.10.pdfCallout192.98 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008639.9.pdfCallout93.47 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008639.pdfExhibit24.08 MB2013-10-08PowerPoint slides, marked as CONFIDENTIAL,
TREX-008640.5.2.BP.pdfCallout78.51 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008640.pdfExhibit1.74 MB2013-10-08PowerPoint slides titled History Matching" of shut-in pressure data
TREX-008642.1.1.BP.pdfCallout42.12 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008642.2.1.BP.pdfCallout45.41 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008642.2.2.BP.pdfCallout60.31 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008642.2.pdfCallout51.02 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008642.pdfExhibit3.69 MB2013-10-08July 21, 2010 E-mail from Paul Hsieh to pflemings@jsg.utexas.edu, Subject: Reservoir volumes, with Attachments, marked as CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-008643.1.1.BP.pdfCallout66.80 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008643.1.pdfCallout84.19 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008643.pdfExhibit214.74 KB2013-10-08Handwritten Notes, marked as CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-008644.1.1.BP.pdfCallout70.27 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008644.15.1.BP.pdfCallout87.25 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008644_Redacted_US.pdfExhibit3.49 MB2013-10-08Aug. 2, 2010 E-mail string between Amy Bowen, Anne Chavez, SCHU and others, Subject: IN LIEU OF DAILY WIT BP SCIENCE CALLS - Daily Well Integrity Updates and Information, with Attachments, marked as CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-008645.1.2.BP.pdfCallout57.52 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008645_Redacted_US.pdfExhibit407.97 KB2013-10-08Aug. 2, 2010 E-mail string from SCHU to Paul Hsieh, Subject: IN LIEU OF DAILY WIT BP SCIENCE CALLS - Daily Well Integrity Updates and Information and Aug. 2, 2010 E-mail string between Paul Hsieh and SCHU, Subject: Rock compressibility
TREX-008647.10.1.BP.pdfCallout56.38 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008647_Redacted_US.pdfExhibit3.59 MB2013-10-08Oct. 8 and 11, 2010 E-mail string between Mark Scogge and Paul Hsieh, Subject: Draft report - MKS feedback, with Attachments, marked as CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-008648.11.1.BP.pdfCallout76.71 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008648.pdfExhibit8.51 MB2013-10-08Oct. 14, 2010 E-mail from Hedeff Essaid to pahsich@usgs.gov, Subject: Colleague Review, with Attachments, marked as CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-008659_Redacted_US.pdfExhibit14.28 MB2013-10-08Notebook of handwritten notes, marked as CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-008660.pdfExhibit26.35 MB2013-10-08BP Powerpoint slides titled Shut the Well in on Paper Benefits and Risks, Paul Tooms dated July 8, 2010,marked as CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-008662.1.1.BP.pdfCallout113.69 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-008662_Redacted_US.pdfExhibit1.15 MB2013-10-08July 31, Aug. 1, 5, 6, 2010 E-mail string among Ronald Dykhuizen, Charles Morrow, Arthur Ratzel and others, Subject: Flow Rate Calculation, marked as CONFIDENTIAL
TREX-008804.pdfExhibit18.34 MB2013-10-08National Incident Command, Interagency Solutions Group, Flow Rate Technical Group, Assessment of Flow Rate Estimates for the Deepwater Horizon/Macondo Well Oil Spill, U.S. Department of the Interior; 134 pages
TREX-009324.17.pdfCallout91.64 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-009324.3.pdfCallout49.32 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-009324.pdfExhibit17.61 MB2013-10-08Email - From: Kate Baker To: Marjorie Tatro and others - Subject: RE: today's presentation, with attachment
TREX-009859.19.2.BP.pdfCallout105.77 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-009859.pdfExhibit6.21 MB2013-10-08Appendix C.1 Kelkar Report Preliminary Report
TREX-010031.pdfExhibit3.18 MB2013-10-08Environmental Science & Technology Oil Release form Macondo Well MC252 Following the Deepwater Horizon Accident - publication
TREX-011485R.11.3.pdfCallout186.12 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Griffiths
TREX-011485R.9.1.pdfCallout90.41 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Griffiths
TREX-011485R.pdfExpert Report11.73 MB2013-10-08REDACTED Report: Expert Report of Stewart K. Griffiths
TREX-011486R.12.6.pdfCallout95.90 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Griffiths
TREX-011486R.14.1.pdfCallout126.93 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Griffiths
TREX-011486R.29.2.pdfCallout110.38 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Griffiths
TREX-011486R.pdfExpert Report9.33 MB2013-10-08REDACTED Report: Expert Rebuttal Report of Stewart Griffiths
TREX-011488.17.2.pdfCallout96.37 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Griffiths
TREX-011653.27.1.pdfCallout112.57 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Griffiths
TREX-041026.pdfExhibit15.33 MB2013-10-08Appendix W to BP Internal Investigation Report: Dynamic Simulations Deepwater Horizon Incident
TREX-08645.1.1.US.pdfCallout249.79 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Hsieh
TREX-11486R.27.1.US.pdfCallout215.88 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Griffiths
TREX-11486R.27.pdfCallout322.29 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Griffiths
TREX-141394.12.2.US.pdfCallout161.91 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Hsieh
TREX-141394.12.pdfCallout104.33 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-141394.pdfExhibit10.48 MB2013-10-08Macondo Well Integrity Test
TREX-141784.1.1.BP.pdfCallout83.75 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-141784_Redacted_US.pdfExhibit494.92 KB2013-10-08Email from W. Lehr to M. McNutt re: Re: Flow Rate Calculation
TREX-142325.1.3.BP.pdfCallout51.63 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-142325_Redacted_US.pdfExhibit43.10 KB2013-10-08Email from Merrill to Hsieh
TREX-144580.1.pdfCallout561.50 KB2013-10-08BP Callout for Hsieh
TREX-144580.pdfExhibit24.56 MB2013-10-08Jaeger, J., Cook, N.G., Zimmerman,R., Fundamentals of Rock Mechanics (2007)
TREX-41026.57.1.US.pdfCallout204.45 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Griffiths
TREX-41026.57.pdfCallout227.29 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Griffiths
TREX-41026.8.1.US.pdfCallout283.53 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Griffiths
TREX-41026.8.pdfCallout443.56 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Griffiths
TREX-8639.15.1.US.pdfCallout176.36 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Hsieh
TREX-8659.13.1.US.pdfCallout229.10 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Hsieh
TREX-8660N.7.1.US.pdfCallout148.79 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Hsieh
TREX-8660N.8.1.US.pdfCallout247.09 KB2013-10-08US Callout for Hsieh